What Brands Keep Getting Wrong About Influencer Marketing

Influencer marketing mistakes to avoid

Written by Bronica Merchant | June 5, 2025

Influencer marketing is everywhere now. Brands work with influencers to show off their products and reach more people. It can be a great way to grow a business. But here’s the truth many brands keep making the same simple mistakes again and again. These small errors can waste time, money, and even hurt your brand image.

If you’re planning to use influencer marketing, this article will help you do it the right way. Let’s go through the common mistakes you should avoid.

Picking the Wrong Influencer

This is the most common mistake. Some brands choose influencers just because they have many followers. But having followers is not the same as having the right audience.

For example, if you sell baby products and you work with a fashion influencer who mostly talks to teenagers, it won’t help much. It’s better to work with someone whose followers care about what you sell.

Picking the Wrong Influencer

What to do instead:
Check the influencer’s content and who follows them. Make sure their style and audience match your product.

Not Checking for Fake Followers

Some influencers buy fake followers to look popular. These fake accounts don’t like, comment, or buy anything. If you work with someone who has a lot of fake followers, your brand gets nothing from the deal.

What to do instead:
Look at the engagement. If someone has 100,000 followers but only gets 200 likes, something’s off. Use simple tools to check if their followers are real.

Ignoring Micro-Influencers

Big names charge big money. But smaller influencers, also called micro-influencers, often have a closer bond with their followers. People trust them more. Their posts get more real comments and attention.

What to do instead:
Try working with micro-influencers who talk directly to your target buyers. You might get better results without spending a fortune.

Giving Too Much Freedom (Or Too Little)

Some brands let influencers do anything they want. Others give them a full script. Both can go wrong.

If you control too much, the post feels fake. If you don’t guide them at all, the message may be unclear or even wrong.

What to do instead:
Give clear instructions but allow room for their voice and style. Good influencers know what works with their followers.

Only Focusing on Likes

Likes look good, but they don’t always mean success. What matters more is if people trust the post, click on the link, or buy the product.

Only Focusing on Likes

What to do instead:
Look at the bigger picture. Are people asking questions? Are they clicking your page? Track real results, not just likes.

One-Time Campaigns

One post and done? That doesn’t always work. If people only see your brand once, they might forget it. Good marketing takes time.

What to do instead:
Build a long-term relationship with the influencer. Let their followers see your brand again and again. That’s how trust builds.

No Contract or Agreement

Skipping contracts can lead to big problems. Maybe the influencer doesn’t post on time. Or they say things you don’t agree with. Without an agreement, you have no control.

What to do instead:
Always use a clear agreement. Write down the post date, what to include, and what not to do. It keeps both sides safe.

Bad Timing

Some brands ask for posts during slow seasons or at the wrong time of day. Even good posts won’t work if no one sees them.

What to do instead:
Work with the influencer to post at peak times. Plan around sales, events, or holidays when people are more likely to buy.

Not Tracking Results

You spent money, but now what? Many brands forget to track how well the campaign did. This makes it hard to know what worked or what didn’t.

What to do instead:
Use basic tools to track visits, clicks, and sales. Some platforms even show how many people came through an influencer’s link.

Not Respecting the Influencer’s Style

Every influencer has their own way of speaking, posing, and writing. If you ask them to sound totally different, the post won’t feel real. Their followers will notice and may lose interest.

What to do instead:
Let them use their own tone. It keeps the post natural and helps it do better.

Forgetting the Legal Side

Some rules say influencers must mention when a post is paid. If they don’t, both of you could get into trouble.

What to do instead:
Make sure every paid post includes a tag like #ad or #sponsored. It’s simple, honest, and keeps your brand safe.

Not Doing Your Homework

Some brands rush and say yes to the first influencer they find. But not all influencers are the same. Some may not fit your values, or they may have had drama in the past.

What to do instead:
Spend a little time reading their past posts, comments, and stories. Make sure they’re a good fit and don’t bring risk to your brand.

Expecting Fast Results

Influencer marketing is not a one-day wonder. You may not see a big change overnight. It takes time for people to notice and trust your brand.

Expecting Fast Results

What to do instead:
Be patient. Look at the results after a week, not an hour. Good marketing always takes time.

Not Talking to the Influencer After the Post

Some brands vanish after the post goes live. This makes the influencer feel like they were just used for one task.

What to do instead:
Stay in touch. Thank them, ask how it went, and plan future ideas. A good bond leads to better posts next time.

Final Thoughts

Influencer marketing can do wonders for your brand. But only if you avoid the easy mistakes that so many still make. Pick the right influencer. Build a fair plan. Be honest. And track your results.

Remember, working with influencers is like working with people—not just numbers. Show respect, be clear, and plan things well. That’s how you win with influencer marketing.

Tags

Leave a comment